Ninth Circuit Jury Holds TIG Liable for Libby Mine Asbestos Claims
On Nov. 20, 2026, a Ninth Circuit jury found TIG Insurance liable for underpaying asbestos claims.
Why it matters: The ruling clarifies reinsurer accountability in long-tail toxic tort cases, crucial for GCs managing environmental liability and insurance portfolios.
- Nov. 20, 2026 jury awards National Indemnity $39.2M indemnity plus $40.4M in interest and expenses.
- National Indemnity covered Montana asbestos claims from July 1973 to July 1975; TIG reinsures for same period.
- Following a $157M National Indemnity-Montana settlement in 2022, TIG paid $12.7M of a $101M reimbursement claim and disputed more.
- Jury found National Indemnity fulfilled contract obligations; TIG breached contract by underpaying claims.
On November 20, 2026, a federal jury in the Ninth Circuit ruled against TIG Insurance Company, holding the reinsurer liable for underpaying claims tied to asbestos exposure from Montana's Libby Mine. CourtHouse News reported details on the verdict, which affects reinsurer responsibilities in long-tail environmental liability cases.
The Libby Mine operated in the early 1970s, extracting vermiculite contaminated with asbestos fibers that caused extensive health issues. National Indemnity insured Montana's asbestos claims from July 1, 1973, to July 1, 1975. TIG reinsured National Indemnity for the same period under a reinsurance certificate, a contract where the reinsurer agrees to cover portions of claims paid by the insurer.
In 2022, Montana and National Indemnity settled asbestos claims for $157 million. National Indemnity invoiced reinsurers over $101 million for their share of the settlement. TIG paid just $12.7 million and disputed additional liability.
The jury awarded National Indemnity $39.2 million in indemnity and $40.4 million in interest and related expenses—$3.2 million in prejudgment interest (accumulated before the verdict) and $21.1 million in postjudgment interest—plus $16.1 million in expenses linked to the dispute. The court found National Indemnity upheld its duties including claims management and disclosure, while TIG breached the agreement by underpaying.
Michael Knoerzer, attorney for National Indemnity, commented, "TIG had the opportunity to participate fully in these claims but declined." TIG’s attorney Scott L. Davis responded that the parties disagreed over their payment obligations.
Legal experts, including James Howard, a reinsurance specialist at Legal Risk Advisors, emphasize this case exposes challenges in reinsurer accountability for long-tail tort claims, where evolving health claims and large settlements require clear contract adherence and prompt payments. Howard states, "Reinsurers must exercise transparency and timely cooperation, or risk litigation and damages awards."
General counsel and legal operations professionals should carefully assess insurance and reinsurance terms and deploy claims management technology to ensure compliance and timely payments in environmental liability cases.
By the numbers:
- $157M — Total asbestos settlement between National Indemnity and Montana in 2022
- $101M — Amount National Indemnity invoiced TIG for reimbursement
- $12.7M — TIG’s initial payment against invoiced reimbursement claim
Yes, but: The ruling is subject to appeal, which may prolong final resolution; the timeline and likelihood of appeal outcomes remain uncertain.
What's next: Potential appeals and further litigation may affect reinsurer accountability precedents in long-tail asbestos cases.