Ninth Circuit Revives Lawsuit Over CCW Revocation for Club Ties

3 min readSources: Volokh Conspiracy, Courthouse News

The Ninth Circuit reinstated a man’s lawsuit over CCW license revocation linked to his motorcycle club.

Why it matters: This ruling clarifies limits on law enforcement when revoking concealed-carry licenses based on association rights. It highlights constitutional protections under the Second and First Amendments amid evolving California gun laws.

  • November 20, 2026: Ninth Circuit reversed dismissal of Kenneth Shilling’s lawsuit against San Diego County and Sheriff Kelly Martinez.
  • December 2023: Sheriff Martinez revoked Shilling’s CCW license citing his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, deemed a 'criminal street gang.'
  • Ninth Circuit ruled California sheriffs are not state arms under the Eleventh Amendment, allowing § 1983 claims against them.
  • From January 1, 2024, California shifted from 'may issue' with a moral character test to a 'shall issue' CCW regime with a dangerousness exclusion.

On November 20, 2026, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals revived Kenneth Charles Shilling’s lawsuit challenging the revocation of his concealed-carry weapon (CCW) license by the San Diego County Sheriff. Shilling's license was rescinded in December 2023 by Sheriff Kelly Martinez, who cited his affiliation with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club — which the Sheriff labeled a 'criminal street gang.'

The Ninth Circuit overturned a prior district court ruling that dismissed Shilling’s claims, holding that sheriffs in California counties are not "arms of the state" under the Eleventh Amendment. This determination means sheriffs can be sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for constitutional violations.

The court also identified Sheriff Martinez as the final policymaker for the County regarding definitions and enforcement of the "good moral character" standard tied to CCW licensing. This implicates the County itself in possible liability for the revocation decision.

Significantly, the ruling came amidst California’s gun licensing policy shift effective January 1, 2024. The state moved away from a discretionary "may issue" model requiring a "good moral character" showing to a "shall issue" approach conditioned only on dangerousness exclusion. This legal backdrop informs the case’s implications on Second Amendment rights and associations.

While details on the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club’s exact legal status as a criminal street gang remain unclear, the court’s reinstatement sets the stage for further clarification of constitutional limits on law enforcement’s ability to deny firearm licenses based solely on group membership.

By the numbers:

  • November 20, 2026 — Date of Ninth Circuit's decision reinstating lawsuit
  • December 2023 — Date Kenneth Shilling’s CCW license was revoked
  • January 1, 2024 — Effective date of California's new 'shall issue' CCW licensing framework

Yes, but: The case does not yet clarify whether the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club qualifies as a legally recognized criminal street gang, which may affect the ultimate outcome.

What's next: Further proceedings in district court will address the constitutional claims arising from the license revocation under the new California licensing regime.